Chat! culturecrossfire.slack.com

MLB Regular Season 2021

alkeiper

Welcoming our new insect overlords
Messages
10,609
Reaction score
2,097
Points
253
Location
Northeast Pennsylvania
We're at the point of the season where teams collectively have about 600-700 plate appearances apiece. I think it's interesting because it kind of shows you what kind of sample size that really is. You don't get huge shifts or flukes. But you do see teams whose batting average is 20-30 points off the mark. That happens with individual player seasons and sometimes we forget that even in a full season a lot is chance.

Offensive is down so far, but it's only April. Runs/game lowest since 2015. Hits/game (7.64) is lowest EVER, batting average lowest ever. Home runs down but still historically high. Steals per game lowest since 1967. Caught stealing lowest ever. Strikeouts/game again at a record high. Double plays are at a record low and oddly hit batters are on a record high pace.
 

Dandy

Posts: 3,237
Messages
4,987
Reaction score
1,461
Points
198
Location
Huntington, WV
On the hits/game average, how many games have not gone 9 innings this year due to the 7 inning twinbill rule? Is that taken into consideration? Every doubleheader is now 4 innings shorter unless there are extra innings.
 

alkeiper

Welcoming our new insect overlords
Messages
10,609
Reaction score
2,097
Points
253
Location
Northeast Pennsylvania
On the hits/game average, how many games have not gone 9 innings this year due to the 7 inning twinbill rule? Is that taken into consideration? Every doubleheader is now 4 innings shorter unless there are extra innings.
Crap. That really throws off the rubric. The pitching side has hits per nine, so I can use that. It puts 2021 in second place behind 1908 and tied with 1968. But then it makes the strikeout increase even more profound. 9.4 per nine.
 

Dandy

Posts: 3,237
Messages
4,987
Reaction score
1,461
Points
198
Location
Huntington, WV
I can go way more in-depth later when I have the time, but the extreme shifts are drastically cutting down the hits. Obviously it is not the only factor as pitching velocity and spin rate is making it harder to hit. However, you can look no further than hit probability or xBA on balls that are outs to get a good idea of what hitting into these shifts is doing. Also included in that is normal shading based on scouting data, but the extreme shifts are doing the bulk of the work. Joey Votto, for instance, was crushing the ball with great Exit Velocity and had a very high xBA compared to his BA. Unlucky? Some. But from watching every game, I can tell you that he just couldn’t get those balls through the shift.


It seems to me that using the bag at second and the skin to grass outfield areas as boundaries for defensive alignment prior to the pitch is what is needed. It is also a simple rule to implement. The infield must have two defenders on each side of second base and cannot be in the outfield grass prior to the pitch. The three outfielders cannot be on the infield dirt prior to the pitch.

The shifts have gotten not only more frequent, but they have evolved quite a bit. There is now a fourth outfielder for all intents and purposes play shallow right. That player is athletic and has a strong arm, and is often the shortstop in these more extreme shifts. So even balls that are hit hard enough to get through the infield are outs from short right field.

Shifts have, in a way, created the launch angle craze as it doesn’t matter how they shift you on the field if you hit it over the fence “where they ain’t.” It has led to higher K% in my mind by virtue of hitters swinging for more home runs.

Want to change the game to trend back toward the norms? Enact a rule that limits the shift.
 

alkeiper

Welcoming our new insect overlords
Messages
10,609
Reaction score
2,097
Points
253
Location
Northeast Pennsylvania
The trouble with the shifts theory is that Babip (Batting average of balls in play) is not historically low. It's .284 this year, down from .292 last year and .298 in 2019. That's a precipitous drop, but there's a lot of noise in the data and shifts didn't just appear this year. Strikeouts have spiked, two more a game (one per team) in the last five years and four more a game in the last ten. On a certain level it doesn't matter where the fielders play since batters have never put the ball in play less than baseball history. (For what it's worth, I believe defense has never been better. Center fielders make unbelievable plays now.) Personally I think a better solution is make pitchers pace themselves and pitch longer, but batters would crush them.
 

strummer

Integral Poster
Messages
8,070
Reaction score
888
Points
218
Was actually going to post something akin to this the other day. Honestly this season has been a bore to watch so far. Hitters seem to have trouble catching up to fastballs. I mean it's plainly obvious. Offense is down. Can't say it's been an exciting season so far
 

strummer

Integral Poster
Messages
8,070
Reaction score
888
Points
218
And the other day on the Mets telecast they were saying there's been talk of moving the mound back. Actually wouldn't mind that at this point
 

Dandy

Posts: 3,237
Messages
4,987
Reaction score
1,461
Points
198
Location
Huntington, WV
@alkeiper, I was speaking about since extreme shifts became more frequent. They have increased over the last several years.

Votto’s specific data was this year; overall, shifts have had a drastic effect on offense over the last few years.
 

Gert

Integral Poster
Messages
4,467
Reaction score
348
Points
168
Want to change the game to trend back toward the norms? Enact a rule that limits the shift.
The Atlantic League (I believe?) or one of the other minor leagues is testing that rule out among others this season.

Crazy finish in Oakland today, as the A's scored 3 runs in the bottom of the 10th without a hit to beat the Twins 13-12 for their 11th straight victory.
 

alkeiper

Welcoming our new insect overlords
Messages
10,609
Reaction score
2,097
Points
253
Location
Northeast Pennsylvania
I tuned into that game and somehow caught despite multiple demands by my daughter to read every message in her game. Including during the final play.
 

geniusMoment

Trailer Park Supervisor
Messages
4,503
Reaction score
1,079
Points
188
If you want more hits forget about banning the shift. Just have all the hitters in the league face the Reds bullpen. Jesus fucking christ.
 

Cartman

Integral Poster
Messages
2,354
Reaction score
56
Points
128
Location
Cumberland, RI
It may not be all the Shifts to blame, but the shifts absolutely have changed the way hitters approach at-bats overall. Strikeouts are way up because hitters that get drastic shifts are just going to swing for the fences more often (launch angle), and would clearly rather K than hit into a DP with runners on base as well. I'm all for changes to the game like moving the mound a bit, but they definitely need to address the shifts AND the Pitch Clock needs to be implemented as it has in the Minors for years.
 

strummer

Integral Poster
Messages
8,070
Reaction score
888
Points
218
The Mets must still think it's 2016 because they can't get Kris Bryant or Anthony Rizzo out. This team is borderline unwatchable they are so boring
 

alkeiper

Welcoming our new insect overlords
Messages
10,609
Reaction score
2,097
Points
253
Location
Northeast Pennsylvania
The Mets have now lost 40 of their last 55 games at Wrigley Field (reg. Season)
Checked it out for myself, you need to go back to 2003. They're 28-29 at home in that span against the Cubs.

Pitc
RkFranchiseTmGWLW-L%RSRAhmW-LrdW-LGames_list
1Arizona DiamondbacksARI1136053.53151547030-2530-28games
2Atlanta BravesATL326143183.4391282147175-8868-95games
3Baltimore OriolesBAL241410.583121937-57-5games
4Boston Red SoxBOS16610.37567791-45-6games
5Chicago CubsCHC1124369.38445155528-2915-40games
6Chicago White SoxCHW1064.60030232-34-1games
7Cincinnati RedsCIN1116645.59552744432-2534-20games
8Cleveland IndiansCLE15114.73374625-16-3games
9Colorado RockiesCOL1186454.54259652738-2026-34games
10Detroit TigersDET211110.5241181057-54-5games
11Houston AstrosHOU734033.54830126525-1215-21games
12Kansas City RoyalsKCR1376.53849433-24-4games
13Los Angeles Angels of AnaheimLAA ANA1899.500831054-55-4games
14Los Angeles DodgersLAD1154966.42645750723-3126-35games
15Miami MarlinsMIA FLA328168160.5121433134288-8080-80games
16Milwaukee BrewersMIL1105060.45548752324-3226-28games
17Minnesota TwinsMIN19127.63296727-45-3games
18New York YankeesNYY984256.42942848920-2722-29games
19Oakland AthleticsOAK16106.62581608-32-3games
20Philadelphia PhilliesPHI332173159.5211586150984-8089-79games
21Pittsburgh PiratesPIT1145955.51849549034-2425-31games
22San Diego PadresSDP1115358.47746844631-2322-35games
23San Francisco GiantsSFG1116150.55047643130-2431-26games
24Seattle MarinersSEA15510.33338852-43-6games
Pitc
25St. Louis CardinalsSTL1145163.44748552033-2718-36games
26Tampa Bay RaysTBR1578.46768623-64-2games
27Texas RangersTEX16106.625102765-35-3games
28Toronto Blue JaysTOR1789.47184893-15-8games
29Washington NationalsWSN MON326152174.4661317145369-9683-78games
282713901437.4921231512396721-689669-748

[thead] [/thead]


[thead] [/thead]



Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 4/23/2021.

Similar records of futility. The Twins are 13-43 at Yankee Stadium(s). The Pirates are 15-43 at Dodger Stadium.

Fun stuff digging through other data. The Rockies are 92-71 against the Giants at home since 2003. On the road, 63-102. The home park is the difference between playing like a 90 win team and a 100 loss team.
 

Brocklock

Integral Poster
Messages
9,188
Reaction score
1,633
Points
228
Location
Illinois
Cubs offense finally showing up the last few games has been fun to watch. It was really disheartening to see guys like Bryant, Baez, and Rizzo play like that, but they are all starting to really heat up. They are currently putting a 10-0 whooping through 3 innings on The Brewers. The NL Central feels up for grabs again like the usual and you could probably win the division without an amazing record.
 

alkeiper

Welcoming our new insect overlords
Messages
10,609
Reaction score
2,097
Points
253
Location
Northeast Pennsylvania
Willians Astudillo caught my eye as a Phillies prospect, he had a year in Venezuela where he hit .361 in 220 plate appearances and struck out twice. But with that body, not a real prospect. Keeps hitting, willing to do anything on a baseball diamond. His ability to make contact is unreal and god he’s a fun player. He’s the first player in 20 years to strike out in less than 5% of his plate appearances.

Today Astudillo swung at a pitch at eye level and drove it over the fence.
 

Aero

Integral Poster
Messages
2,270
Reaction score
135
Points
113
A privilege to watch. Gave up two hits, but had two hits of his own.
 
Top