I don't actually watch anything other than WWE these days, so that's why this will all be WWE-centric.
Wrestler of the Year: AJ Styles
Promotion of the Year: WWE
Best Major Wrestling Show: NXT Takeover: Wargames
Best Weekly TV Show: WWE RAW
Best Match of the Year: Tyler Bate vs. Pete Dunne, NXT Takeover: Chicago
Most Underrated (by the company): Sami Zayn
Feud of the Year: Roman Reigns vs. Braun Strowman
Tag Team of the Year: The Bar (Cesaro/Sheamus)
Most Improved: Braun Strowman
Best on Interviews: The Miz
Best Television Announcer: Nigel McGuinness
Worst Wrestler: Titus O'Neil (I was tempted to pick somebody else because he doesn't wrestle much anymore, but realistically Titus is the bottom of the barrel.)
Worst Promotion of the Year: N/A
Worst Major Wrestling Show: WWE Battleground
Worst Television Show: WWE Smackdown
Worst Match of the Year: Randy Orton vs. Jinder Mahal, WWE Battleground
Most Overrated (by the company): Randy Orton
Worst Feud of the Year: Randy Orton vs. Jinder Mahal
Worst Television Announcer: Byron Saxton
Some others or "b class"
Best Return: Kurt Angle
Most Disappointing Return/Surprise: Rusev. It looked like they were going to re-introduce him as a new title contender for his return back in the spring and then it was all abandoned and they did absolutely nothing with him.
Best Finisher: Brock Lesnar's F5
Best/Worst Angle/skit: Best - "I'm not finished with you!" Worst - This is you life, Bayley.
Best/Worst Celebrity Moment: Best - Gronk at Wrestlemania. Worst - The Ball Family.
"Why Do I Still Watch?" Moment: Jinder Mahal wins WWE World Title
"THIS Is Why I Still Watch!" Moment: Kurt Angle returns to the ring at TLC
Best/Worst Entrance Music: Best - Bobby Roode, Worst - Baron Corbin (current)