Babyface options for the AWA circa Jan 1984 (assuming to build a few months to beating Bock/Jumbo:
In house:
- Greg Gagne - supposedly Verne knew this was taboo, but the fans in 84 would have been okay with it, but it would be historically seen as a disaster given Gagne wasn't a charisma machine or a body guy. A HELL of a worker though.
- Jim Brunzell - yes Vince used him as cannon fodder, but he would have been "fine" as a top AWA guy. Probably the near exact same level that Martel achieved.
- Brad Rheingans - Verne tried for years but Brad was "aggressively bland"
The over the hill gang: The Blackjacks, Mad Dog Vachon, Baron VR, Crusher, Billy Robinson.
Montreal - Dino Bravo (Bleh)
- Prelims; Rapey Zumhofe and Steve O
Soon to come in:
Tony Atlas in summer.
(Heel side is F'N loaded BTW: Patera, Blackwell, SS Graham, Saito, Ventura, Ray Stevens, Harley Race, and Brody and Abby were coming in for the spring/summer)
--
The perfect answer would be for Verne to see the future in Oct of 83 and instead of figuring Hogan is staying around, Verne instead knows he needs to court Dusty Rhodes to come in and book. Dusty is by no means going to come in with Hogan entrenched as the top mega face. Dusty can book himself in the top circle while building up the next batch of stars.
Steamboat - Fresh off retirement in early 1984, perhaps Steamboat skips the business quitting and jumps from JCP to the AWA to be the champ. Potentially excellent matches, but the promos are at best slightly better than Martel's.
Bob Backlund - If Bob realizes sooner he's old news to Vince Jr, he can hop right to the AWA off his title loss and win the AWA title. He was the pure athlete Verne loved and from Minnesota. His AWA run in late 84/early 85 didn't get over. As I've mentioned many times on CXF, Bob's Pro Wrestling USA promos were more like Waylon Mercy than a top babyface. AWA wanted to give him a belt in 85 and created the Americas title for him to chase and win so he could be a major champ again and restore himself, but he fell so flat that the plan was scrapped and Sarge won it from Zybyszko instead.
Young guns - Windham, Rotunda, Magnum TA, Terry Taylor- Windham was probably the closest to being ready for a major run, but he proved in 84/85 that he was very flaky and quit both JCP and WWF in the middle of big pushes.
Magnum wasn't ready and would need 1984 to build himself up.
Taylor was also better served as the friend of Denzel and not Denzel...err the buddy of the top face. Taylor wound up screwing himself over the rest of the 80s, but the before 1985 he was a hot prospect.
Rotunda was also a prospect with a legit background, but his charisma wasn't good in the least. He was hyped in the early 80s as a future NWA champ prospect.
JYD - He might get over by the sheer force of charisma, but by 1984 he was getting chunky and he was a 3 out of 10 in the ring, which Verne would not sniff as a champion option. (JYD did squash Bock in Houston in 83)
Dr Death - too raw and no promo
Curt Hennig - too young/bland promo yet He and his Dad forming a team was perfect for 84.
Lawler - not loyal to Verne, small, good promo but didn't have the rabid fanbase anywhere but Memphis despite touring the AWA etc.
Wahoo - aging out - would have been fine for a short run. Just had a big feud w/ Bock in 83 IIRC though.
Austin Idol - if he had an extended run, he may have gotten over? I'm not sure he ever worked for Verne other than Pro WUSA
Tommy Rich - southern brawler, getting flabby, maybe too small for a serious champ in a territory he wasn't already beloved in?
Hacksaw Duggan - good size, good promo, legit background, maybe a dark horse to be the "Crusher" of the 80s for Verne. (Again only worked for PWUSA and never the AWA IIRC)
Macho Man - Had he been more nationally seasoned, Savage could have been a phenom for Verne, but Vince would have likely sniped him ASAP instead of waiting for June of 1985.
Do you hold off for the Blackwell babyface switch and put the belt on him? He was massively over and probably didn't need the belt given he was part of the hottest program of 1984-1986 vs Sheik/Brody and friends.
** Jesse Ventura leaves in May, but Verne had asked him to turn face to replace Hogan. I don't see Verne slapping the belt on Jesse given he was dreadful in the ring, but I figured I should add this note.