Heretic (2024) comes oh so close to transcending itself after building layer of tension upon layer of tension but falls just short of pure greatness by deciding to hold itself back. This isn't a case where a horror film's own conservative approach on its material ruins the concept, though, as the end result is still extremely good.
Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East) are members of the Church of Latter-Day Saints on mission, when they come across the house of a Mr. Reed (Hugh Grant), who welcomes them inside for a theological chat. All seems fine initially until Reed begins to push them on their beliefs, revealing himself to be much more than just a theological scholar, and indeed something much more sinister.
Grant is incredible in this role, as he utilizes all of the same tools that made him an international superstar of romantic comedies in the 90s but gives them a menacing twist, not unlike his turn in Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves but with considerably more malice and less of an appetite for scenery. Truthfully, I'd even say he deserved a nomination for his turn here, as it's a major career highlight. Not to be outclassed, Thatcher brings her A-game, with East being the weakest link of the three, but by no means a hindrance to the work.
Really, writers/directors Scott Beck and Bryan Wood, best known for the aged-like-cheap-beer A Quiet Place and overbudgeted b-movie 5.4, deserve a massive amount of acclaim. This has to be their best work to date, the crowning achievement of their approach to genre, as the plot weaves in and out of philosophical discussions about the world's religions and faith as a concept, dabbling into conspiracy theory at just the right moments, all to highlight the sinsister game that Mr. Reed is playing with the two young women.
With so much praise, where does it falter? Like with A Quiet Place, in the final act. The tension reaches a fever pitch only to find a resolution too reliant on dialogue to captivatingly close the chapter. It does send us home with visuals that tie into earlier discussions about what happens after we die, which is a major bonus, but it does come across as a bit anti-climactic given how incredible the ride has been up until one of the characters is shockingly taken out of the equation.
7.5/10, a must-see that has the chance of getting better with age.