You Were Never Really Here (2018), directed by Lynne Ramsey
For whatever reason, reviewing You Were Never Really Here is proving difficult to tackle. I have had this file open for over two hours now, and I don't know what I should say. While I knew this movie was raw and violent, I suppose I wasn't prepared for just how far this movie would go. I don't want to be prepared, but you know how that goes. I am very surprised that this film wasn't released in 2017 or 2018's awards season. I would think that Amazon would sit on this one and launch it during a period where they had very little in terms of potential award winners. Obviously, they did not. Amazon usually has pretty good movies, but they never release them in a way that is beneficial towards the film and its awards chances. This might be my favorite of the movies that they've released. I'd also say it's better than Manchester by the Sea. So, why do movies like this not get the publicity that the people who see them believe that those films deserve? I can't answer this. This film is also one that disputes the long held idea in Hollywood that women can't direct violent movies, or movies with action. I believe this is something that came up when Black Widow was in production. Imagine being so idiotic that you think women can't direct a certain kind of anything. Yet, three years after You Were Never Really Here premiered at Cannes, things in Hollywood seem to be pretty much the same. You know, with the exception of the whole coronavirus thing.
You Were Never Really Here is a very short film which is very easy to sum up. Joe (Joaquin Phoenix) is a hired gun who specializes in retrieving kidnapped girls from those who stole and trafficked them. Joe is very good at his job, but he's also traumatized from his past serving in Iraq and working for the FBI. Suicidal thoughts are a regular part of his day. He usually imagines suffocating himself with a bag, or actually does it just to see how far he can actually go. He doesn't go all the way, or there wouldn't be a movie at all. When we meet Joe, he's on a job in Cincinnati during which he brutally deals with a problem. After returning to New York City, we see that he lives with his mom (Judith Roberts). His mom needs help as she's quite old. Anyway, Joe is what we would call adequate help as he's too damaged do very much. Except, we learn that the thing in Cincinnati was a job. Joe prefers to have a middleman, and in this case his is Angel (Frank Pando). There is an issue though. For one, Angel knows his address. The second thing is that his son Moises (Vinicius Damasceno) sees Joe one day when he's walking in. So, Joe wants this middleman ditched for another one.
In order for that to happen, we have to see Joe's actual boss. John McCleary (John Doman) seems to be a handler of sorts, and everyone knows this is who you go to if you need to deal with a kidnapping and don't want the police to do it. Joe's next job is dealing with a New York State Senator, Albert Votto (Alex Manette). Votto has told Joe that his daughter Nina (Ekaterina Samsonov) has been kidnapped and forced to work in a brothel. Votto is running for re-election, so this needs to be handled very quietly. Or, in Joe's case, very brutally but in a way not involving the police. The thing is, when there's this kind of Jeffrey Epstein shit going on, a lot of people can be involved. When Joe's done retrieving Nina, it's clear that one of them could knock on his door at any moment. They may, for example, track him down to a hotel and locate the clerk. They also may shoot that clerk and murder him right in front of Joe. What happens after that?
You Were Never Really Here is a movie that can be described as an assault on the senses, and it is another movie where Joaquin Phoenix performed better than he did in Joker. I think there are one or two more in that category. Some of the things in this movie go so goddamn far I could hardly believe what I was watching. Everything here is going right for the viewer and making them care. Only really good filmmakers are able to accomplish that. There is a particularly devious scene near the end that actually bothered me as it was going on. The film's editing and sound also does the entire project a great service. I find that You Were Never Really Here is the kind of film I really look forward to watching, and it is also the kind of film I wish I had been able to watch sooner once I actually get around to watching it. I cannot reiterate enough that this is a very strong performance. The movie is also entirely about Phoenix's character and everything else barely rates. His motivations are spelled out and made clear. The story is uniquely focused on him and not extraneous factors.
I don't think this is truly a movie for everyone, but I believe it is a movie made for way more people than those who actually bothered to see it. There's a scene at a lake that doesn't really do anything for me, but other than that it feels like You Were Never Really Here was a film made for me.
The scene pictured above, by the way, is a perfect way to film violence in this century. We've seen it all before, but this is a different way of looking at things. If you haven't watched this already, you should.
9/10
2018 Films Ranked
1. Roma
2. A Star Is Born
3. First Reformed
4. The Favourite
5. You Were Never Really Here
6. Widows
7. First Man
8. BlacKkKlansman
9. Blindspotting
10. Leave No Trace
11. Black Panther
12. If Beale Street Could Talk
13. The Sisters Brothers
14. A Private War
15. Avengers: Infinity War
16. Stan & Ollie
17. Green Book
18. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse
19. Mission: Impossible - Fallout
20. The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
21. On My Skin
22. Private Life
23. Climax
24. Can You Ever Forgive Me?
25. Mid90s
26. Eighth Grade
27. Sorry to Bother You
28. Suspiria
29. The Death of Stalin
30. A Quiet Place
31. Vice
32. The Old Man & the Gun
33. Vox Lux
34. Bad Times at the El Royale
35. The Other Side of the Wind
36. Searching
37. A Simple Favor
38. The Hate U Give
39. Unsane
40. Disobedience
41. Boy Erased
42. Bumblebee
43. Mary Poppins Returns
44. Creed II
45. Hold the Dark
46. The Land of Steady Habits
47. Halloween
48. Ant-Man and the Wasp
49. The Miseducation of Cameron Post
50. Blockers
51. Beirut
52. Roxanne Roxanne
53. Tully
54. Mary Queen of Scots
55. Aquaman
56. Ideal Home
57. Outlaw King
58. Overlord
59. Ready Player One
60. Ben Is Back
61. Monsters and Men
62. The Mule
63. On the Basis of Sex
64. Bohemian Rhapsody
65. White Boy Rick
66. Papillon
67. Game Night
68. Sicario 2: Day of the Soldado
69. Ocean's Eight
70. Alpha
71. Come Sunday
72. Instant Family
73. The Front Runner
74. The Predator
75. Apostle
76. Uncle Drew
77. The Cured
78. The Commuter
79. The Angel
80. Tag
81. Beautiful Boy
82. The Nun
83. Operation Finale
84. The Equalizer 2
85. The Spy Who Dumped Me
86. Cargo
87. Yardie
88. Bird Box
89. 12 Strong
90. Venom
91. Skyscraper
92. The Meg
93. Assassination Nation
94. Crazy Rich Asians
95. Backstabbing for Beginners
96. The Girl in the Spider's Web
97. The House with a Clock in Its Walls
98. 22 July
99. Tomb Raider
100. Rampage
101. Hotel Artemis
102. Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom
103. The Little Stranger
104. 7 Days in Entebbe
105. Night School
106. The 15:17 To Paris
107. Den of Thieves
108. The Catcher Was a Spy
109. Peppermint
110. Mile 22
111. The First Purge
112. Hunter Killer
113. The Hurricane Heist
114. The Cloverfield Paradox
115. Breaking In
116. Mute
117. Kin
118. Hell Fest
119. Proud Mary
120. Robin Hood
121. Traffik
122. Winchester
123. The Happytime Murders
124. The Outsider
125. Slender Man
2. A Star Is Born
3. First Reformed
4. The Favourite
5. You Were Never Really Here
6. Widows
7. First Man
8. BlacKkKlansman
9. Blindspotting
10. Leave No Trace
11. Black Panther
12. If Beale Street Could Talk
13. The Sisters Brothers
14. A Private War
15. Avengers: Infinity War
16. Stan & Ollie
17. Green Book
18. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse
19. Mission: Impossible - Fallout
20. The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
21. On My Skin
22. Private Life
23. Climax
24. Can You Ever Forgive Me?
25. Mid90s
26. Eighth Grade
27. Sorry to Bother You
28. Suspiria
29. The Death of Stalin
30. A Quiet Place
31. Vice
32. The Old Man & the Gun
33. Vox Lux
34. Bad Times at the El Royale
35. The Other Side of the Wind
36. Searching
37. A Simple Favor
38. The Hate U Give
39. Unsane
40. Disobedience
41. Boy Erased
42. Bumblebee
43. Mary Poppins Returns
44. Creed II
45. Hold the Dark
46. The Land of Steady Habits
47. Halloween
48. Ant-Man and the Wasp
49. The Miseducation of Cameron Post
50. Blockers
51. Beirut
52. Roxanne Roxanne
53. Tully
54. Mary Queen of Scots
55. Aquaman
56. Ideal Home
57. Outlaw King
58. Overlord
59. Ready Player One
60. Ben Is Back
61. Monsters and Men
62. The Mule
63. On the Basis of Sex
64. Bohemian Rhapsody
65. White Boy Rick
66. Papillon
67. Game Night
68. Sicario 2: Day of the Soldado
69. Ocean's Eight
70. Alpha
71. Come Sunday
72. Instant Family
73. The Front Runner
74. The Predator
75. Apostle
76. Uncle Drew
77. The Cured
78. The Commuter
79. The Angel
80. Tag
81. Beautiful Boy
82. The Nun
83. Operation Finale
84. The Equalizer 2
85. The Spy Who Dumped Me
86. Cargo
87. Yardie
88. Bird Box
89. 12 Strong
90. Venom
91. Skyscraper
92. The Meg
93. Assassination Nation
94. Crazy Rich Asians
95. Backstabbing for Beginners
96. The Girl in the Spider's Web
97. The House with a Clock in Its Walls
98. 22 July
99. Tomb Raider
100. Rampage
101. Hotel Artemis
102. Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom
103. The Little Stranger
104. 7 Days in Entebbe
105. Night School
106. The 15:17 To Paris
107. Den of Thieves
108. The Catcher Was a Spy
109. Peppermint
110. Mile 22
111. The First Purge
112. Hunter Killer
113. The Hurricane Heist
114. The Cloverfield Paradox
115. Breaking In
116. Mute
117. Kin
118. Hell Fest
119. Proud Mary
120. Robin Hood
121. Traffik
122. Winchester
123. The Happytime Murders
124. The Outsider
125. Slender Man