Alright, so I don't want to do a full review of Many Saints of Newark because then I'd have to detail the plot. I do have a lot to say though.
I gave the movie a 5.
Why a 5? I felt like this was a completely unfocused work in almost every respect and was surprised David Chase would make something like this. There are a lot of very big mistakes here. I would say chiefly among them is the use of preexisting characters. Shoehorning adult Pussy and Silvio into the story while Tony is a little kid makes the movie feel inauthentic. Those guys weren't that old. Silvio is nearly the same age as Junior in this movie. I thought Chase also comes dangerously close to turning his characters into full blown pastiche. The imitations here are genuinely terrible and nauseating. There is no need for the actors to imitate the characters from the show. Do your own thing to some extent, because you can't act like this and ruin the movie. It doesn't feel natural because they're trying to hit notes that other actors accomplished. As a result Gandolfini, Farmiga, and Bernthal's performances are the only ones of existing characters to feel authentic.
There are other flaws besides just these, and they're mostly in relation to there not being a story in this film until it's too late. Eventually you see what the movie is supposed to be about, but everything before that feels almost pointless. Of course there's also Leslie Odom's character which is there for a potential sequel or television series, one which I'm sure we'll have even though I don't understand why we need to have it. I'm gonna be honest here. If I have to watch that guy pretend to be Silvio Dante again? I won't even watch any TV show related to this. Another problem I have here is that what we've learned about the characters from the original series is quite minimal. We learned that Junior had Dickie killed, but that's all we learned.
Of course there were things I liked, most of them related to Tony and Livia Soprano, but I could have done without this and would have preferred it was never made. I said before that this wasn't the Sopranos movie anyone wanted, and that seems obviously true after having seen it. It also goes without saying that any future material related to this show should revolve around Michael Gandolfini as Tony, and that should include an acknowledgment of whether or not Tony lived.