Darkest Hour (2017), directed by Joe Wright
Arguably never before has there been a more easy comparison between two films nominated for awards, with Dunkirk and Darkest Hour coming out in the same year. I am unable to resist doing so myself. Let's face it, how can one not compare the two? They're both about the same event from two different perspectives, one on the ground and the other back at home in London. These are two radically different films in scope, one takes place nearly entirely on set and the other outside, but again, they are about the same event. Comparing the two also very easily exposes the shortcomings of Darkest Hour. I know there are many Churchill fetishists out there, I have a family member who is one of them. I was told by him a while ago that I should watch Darkest Hour and Dunkirk as a double feature, but if I'd done so, this difference would have been even more pronounced. I may even feel negatively about Darkest Hour if I'd done that. What I thought about Dunkirk was that Christopher Nolan's direction really busted down the door to make an absolutely classic film, and in the case of Darkest Hour, the entertainment value is derived from one performance. That is one performance alone in a film with a large ensemble cast, I should note. With that knowledge, I am absolutely mystified as to how this was nominated for awards. However, as this year's Oscars may show, the people who vote for these things may have a huge anglophilia problem. Bohemian Rhapsody is all the real evidence you need to show it's the case.
If you don't know what Darkest Hour is about, I don't know what the fuck's wrong with you. The film begins in 1940 with the Labour Party demanding the resignation of Neville Chamberlain (Ronald Pickup) for reasons that most everyone is aware of. He was weak and he was a coward. Chamberlain wanted to handpick his successor, but for whatever reason Viscount Halifax (Stephen Dillane) has decided the time is not right for him to become Prime Minister of Britain. Chamberlain was also still the leader of the ruling Conservative Party, and in talks with King George VI (Ben Mendelsohn), it is clear that the King does not want this, but everyone has been left with no choice. If you have not realized, Darkest Hour takes some extreme creative liberties with how things worked out. Enter Winston Churchill (Gary Oldman). We pan over to his abode, where he gets angry at his new secretary, Elizabeth Layton (Lily James), because she did not hear him properly. Winston's wife Clementine (Kristin Scott Thomas) does not like this, so in the end Miss Layton returns with a telegram. The King has invited Churchill to Buckingham Palace to form a government, which as anyone could tell, is exactly what happens. Churchill is a smart man, so he includes Chamberlain and Halifax in his war cabinet as they receive news that Hitler has invaded Belgium and the Netherlands.
Churchill has a poor reputation in Parliament due to prior conduct, but the three parties thought he would be the best Prime Minister. He was the right man at the right job at the right time as it has been said. Churchill is instantly met with major problems, of course. He travels to France and the French PM finds him to be delusional, because what Churchill says is completely deluded. Inevitably, we come to the matter of Dunkirk. The British Army was trapped at Dunkirk, and Churchill gives an order to lead a rear-guard action so that the British can buy time to evacuate forces from Dunkirk. We then get to the real heart of the film, the War Cabinet Crisis. Churchill has an outburst at Chamberlain over his prior appeasement strategy, and eventually Chamberlain and Halifax decide to force Churchill's hand. They want him to negotiate for peace, and if he does not they will resign and force a vote of no confidence, to lead to someone challenging Churchill's position. In Halifax's diary, he had written that succeeding Chamberlain would be impossible, this aspect is not really covered in the film. These battles between Halifax and Churchill inevitably spiral, such as you'd expect, but Churchill is forced to consider the idea of suing for peace. And there's your film.
Obviously I left out some major details that happen after Churchill is forced to play his hand, but I think everyone knows what happens from there. Due to Dunkirk using fictional characters, as well as that film's willingness to discard of them, the difference in tension between the two films is quite incredible. This is where we get into the difference between biographies and original films. Gary Oldman's performance is fantastic, I think I'll wind up being in agreement with those who awarded him for that performance. Darkest Hour, however, is entirely reliant upon that performance. The inherent issue with biographies, and if you've noticed the reason why I rarely rate them as highly as other kinds of films, is because a biography really needs to bring some kind of technical innovation or events I don't know about in order to liven things up. The problem here is that I already knew about all this stuff. Most adults should know about this subject as well, and the evacuation of Dunkirk is something that was addressed in a film that arrived earlier in the same year. The release of Dunkirk undoubtedly works against Darkest Hour, but I think there are so many other good films from 2017 that do as well. I haven't watched them all yet either!
Where Darkest Hour really succeeds beyond Oldman's spectacular performance, is technically. Didn't I just say that thing about technical innovation? Space launches, unfortunately for this film and my view towards it, massively surpass those innovations with makeup and fat suits. Plaudits for those things were deserved, I'm not saying that. I also thought the room they used as a stand-in for Buckingham Palace was spectacularly decorated and adorned. This was something I thought every single time the room was on screen, so I thought I would mention it. I rarely mention set design, so that tells you just how much I thought it stood out. The state of the buildings was excellent too, and so was the cinematography. I can't compare it to the some of the other films as I haven't watched them, but there are countless very good shots of Churchill. So, technically, this is brilliant. Some of the other characters, like that of Viscount Halifax, are very well developed and nicely performed. I also never thought Ben Mendelsohn would make a good British king, but here we are. It also feels like this guy is in everything, even though he isn't. That's a good thing in his case.
Ultimately, with all those positives, I think Darkest Hour does have some complete failures to balance them out. The historical accuracy of these events is sometimes incorrect to a point where I could only wonder how the events could have been untangled in a way that everyone could understand. Truthfully, I could not come up with one. There's also some complete fabrications, like with Churchill riding on the London Underground. That scene is totally ludicrous and took me out of the end of the film. I also think that films such as this one, particularly with a figure like Churchill who did bad things, serve to whitewash his sins and make everyone forget about them. I told you about my family member, correct? This is what happens when films fail in that regard. Creatively messing around with what a figure like Winston Churchill really was, I think that's a problem. I do expect that this role is going to be revisited at some point as well, it would surprise me if it wasn't. There's too much ground left uncovered, but I hope that someone else writes the film this time. For my money, even though this is something I would call a good film with some extremely positive aspects, I think the screenwriter did not do what could have been done with the story. So, take it for what it's worth, but this film is not great and just below that. Perhaps if I was British, I would feel different. But I'm not. The film just isn't insightful enough, and I realized that this is currently somewhat high on my list, but that should go down quite a bit by the time I'm done unless 2017 sucked.
7.5/10
2017 Films Ranked
1. Dunkirk
2. Get Out
3. Logan
4. Wonder Woman
5. The Big Sick
6. Thor: Ragnarok
7. Logan Lucky
8. The Beguiled
9. The Meyerowitz Stories (New and Selected)
10. Star Wars: The Last Jedi
11. The Lost City of Z
12. First They Killed My Father
13. Darkest Hour
14. Spider-Man: Homecoming
15. I Don't Feel at Home in This World Anymore
16. It
17. Battle of the Sexes
18. Okja
19. Kong: Skull Island
20. It Comes at Night
21. Split
22. 1922
23. Personal Shopper
24. Chuck
25. Atomic Blonde
26. Wheelman
27. The Lego Batman Movie
28. Megan Leavey
29. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
30. American Made
31. Beauty and the Beast
32. Imperial Dreams
33. Murder on the Orient Express
34. The Zookeeper's Wife
35. Free Fire
36. Win It All
37. The Wall
38. Life
39. Breathe
40. The Man Who Invented Christmas
41. Sleight
42. Alone in Berlin
43. A United Kingdom
44. Trespass Against Us
45. The Mountain Between Us
46. War Machine
47. Happy Death Day
48. Justice League
49. To the Bone
50. Wakefield
51. The Hitman's Bodyguard
52. King Arthur: Legend of the Sword
53. Sand Castle
54. CHiPs
55. Death Note
56. The Belko Experiment
57. The Great Wall
58. Fist Fight
59. Snatched
60. Wilson
61. Queen of the Desert
62. Sleepless
2. Get Out
3. Logan
4. Wonder Woman
5. The Big Sick
6. Thor: Ragnarok
7. Logan Lucky
8. The Beguiled
9. The Meyerowitz Stories (New and Selected)
10. Star Wars: The Last Jedi
11. The Lost City of Z
12. First They Killed My Father
13. Darkest Hour
14. Spider-Man: Homecoming
15. I Don't Feel at Home in This World Anymore
16. It
17. Battle of the Sexes
18. Okja
19. Kong: Skull Island
20. It Comes at Night
21. Split
22. 1922
23. Personal Shopper
24. Chuck
25. Atomic Blonde
26. Wheelman
27. The Lego Batman Movie
28. Megan Leavey
29. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
30. American Made
31. Beauty and the Beast
32. Imperial Dreams
33. Murder on the Orient Express
34. The Zookeeper's Wife
35. Free Fire
36. Win It All
37. The Wall
38. Life
39. Breathe
40. The Man Who Invented Christmas
41. Sleight
42. Alone in Berlin
43. A United Kingdom
44. Trespass Against Us
45. The Mountain Between Us
46. War Machine
47. Happy Death Day
48. Justice League
49. To the Bone
50. Wakefield
51. The Hitman's Bodyguard
52. King Arthur: Legend of the Sword
53. Sand Castle
54. CHiPs
55. Death Note
56. The Belko Experiment
57. The Great Wall
58. Fist Fight
59. Snatched
60. Wilson
61. Queen of the Desert
62. Sleepless