Landline (2017), directed by Gillian Robespierre
When I was making my way through Amazon Studios movies they'd made earlier this decade, I initially skipped Landline. I was waiting until a later date, but part of it was that I wasn't sure I was ready to see a movie that had middling reviews. I did see that this was listed as a comedy, and by that standard Landline had good reviews, so I decided I should go back and give the film a look. This was a good decision, which I realized a few minutes into the film. This feeling was persistent throughout, and that's what I was hoping for. There's lots of comedies that just can't keep momentum going on any level at all, but when the tone shifts into being more of a drama, the film works too. I usually don't come out so strong in favor of a film in my opening paragraph, but I liked this even when I found those flaws to be apparent. Landline didn't make money and there's no real surprise in that regard, I didn't know this even existed until I made my way down a lit. That's often the problem with these Amazon and Netflix releases. The overall awareness of them is not all that great. So, what is Landline actually about? It seems that this film cannot decide which theme it wants to fully commit to, so it decides to give what the writer-director things are insights into those things. In some cases they are insightful and in others they aren't, but in any case, I think I appreciated what I watched until a point. I will leave you hanging on what that point actually is.
Landline begins with Dana Jacobs (Jenny Slate) having sex with her fiance Ben (Jay Duplass) out in the woods, and at this point I wasn't exactly sure what I'd gotten into. After they finish, everyone piles up into a car and they're on their way. It seems like the Jacobs family has a house outside of New York City. Pat (Edie Falco) and Alan (John Turturro) are husband and wife, Dana is their daughter, and they have a younger daughter named Ali (Abby Quinn). Obviously, they're going back to New York City, and it works out that Dana and Ben live together, while the other three live in their own house. So, Ali is that age, the age where she wants to do everything and still has to come home to deal with her parents. She wants to go raves, doesn't want to go to school or do her tests, and more than anything else, she wants to get high. Sounds like a good life to me. Pat and Alan have a weird relationship that often happens with older couples, one becomes disinterested in the other and seems to hate them. This is the case with how Pat behaves towards Alan and it's impossible to explain why this is unless the person says why it is, but that's never stated in this film. It just is how it is, people behave how they behave. Dana and Ben have a pretty good relationship by the standards of this film, I'd say.
While they have a good relationship, the way this film works is that you know it won't be the case forever. One day at a party, Dana runs into a former ex-boyfriend, Nate (Finn Wittrock). It turns out that she is enamored once again with Nate and decides to take off work to go to a record store, where she runs into him. Oh, I left something out. This is 1995, so those record stores still matter, and so do a lot of other things. Nobody has a cell phone, which I suppose matters. I don't know if it really does. At the same time, Ali returns from a rave one night and finds a bombshell, that her dad has written love notes on a floppy disk that she popped in to try to find some files on. The notes are written to a woman dubbed as "C," and they're vulgar, and Alan definitely wrote them. Ali is confronted about going to raves some time after that, but she hasn't said anything about what she knows. She goes with her boyfriend to her family's house outside New York City, but Ali has tried to escape Ben and Nate there as well. Will the two tell each other what they know? To this point of the film anyway, they have been very distant and like to make fun of each other.
So, the director is inspired by a list of things that seemed obvious to me, the largest ones being her commentary on marriage, on cheating, and on being sisters. I actually...don't have any experience with doing either of those things, so I am unqualified as a reviewer to deal with Landline. What I do in a situation like that, is that I don't really deal with it and let the movie speak for itself in those regards. I enjoyed how we had a film with these secrets, but the secrets are only kept from three people who don't know what everyone else knows. Of course, a movie like this one where someone is supposed to get married and they're having a hard time dealing with that, there's a lot of routes the story could go. I think I prefer this one. Ben is a fucking boring guy, and when women realize that they're dating boring guys, this is how some of them react. Men react the same way too, that's human nature. The parental relationship is also an example of what happens when people don't address their incompatibilities prior to getting hitched. The arguments when these things finally come to the forefront are what I would call good cinema, but they aren't great. Great is what happens when you watch "Whitecaps", but the dramatic impact of that moment is simply lacking from this rather short film.
As far as flaws go, even though the movie is set in the 1990s, there are few statements of culture in the film, so I'm confused why this was set in the 1990s in the first place. I also didn't care for the ending lacking true resolution to Alan and Pat's story, but we're left for that being what it is. This also doesn't feel like a film in that the story is extremely intimate, doesn't do anything that shocks you to your core, and that's why Landline isn't a great film. It's merely a good one, but being good is perfectly acceptable and welcome in these times. I'm not familiar with the director at all, but if she creates more work I'll check it out. I thought the family dynamics were very nice and that the sisters felt like complete characters rather than caricatures. That is something I don't see every day.
7/10
2017 Films Ranked
1. Dunkirk
2. Phantom Thread
3. The Shape of Water
4. Get Out
5. Good Time
6. Mudbound
7. Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
8. Logan
9. The Post
10. Wonder Woman
11. The Big Sick
12. Wind River
13. Thor: Ragnarok
14. Logan Lucky
15. The Beguiled
16. The Meyerowitz Stories (New and Selected)
17. Star Wars: The Last Jedi
18. John Wick: Chapter 2
19. The Lost City of Z
20. First They Killed My Father
21. Darkest Hour
22. A Ghost Story
23. Spider-Man: Homecoming
24. I Don't Feel at Home in This World Anymore
25. It
26. Battle of the Sexes
27. Brad's Status
28. Okja
29. Norman: The Moderate Rise and Tragic Fall of a New York Fixer
30. Kong: Skull Island
31. It Comes at Night
32. Crown Heights
33. Split
34. 1922
35. Personal Shopper
36. Landline
37. Beatriz at Dinner
38. Chuck
39. Atomic Blonde
40. Wheelman
41. The Lego Batman Movie
42. Megan Leavey
43. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
44. Marshall
45. Menashe
46. Walking Out
47. American Made
48. Beauty and the Beast
49. Imperial Dreams
50. Gifted
51. Murder on the Orient Express
52. The Zookeeper's Wife
53. Free Fire
54. Win It All
55. The Wall
56. Life
57. My Cousin Rachel
58. Breathe
59. The Man Who Invented Christmas
60. Maudie
61. Sleight
62. Alone in Berlin
63. A United Kingdom
64. Trespass Against Us
65. The Mountain Between Us
66. War Machine
67. Happy Death Day
68. Lowriders
69. Justice League
70. To the Bone
71. Ghost in the Shell
72. Wakefield
73. Bright
74. The Hitman's Bodyguard
75. XXX: Return of Xander Cage
76. The Mummy
77. The Greatest Showman
78. Rough Night
79. King Arthur: Legend of the Sword
80. Sand Castle
81. The Circle
82. CHiPs
83. Death Note
84. The Belko Experiment
85. The Great Wall
86. Fist Fight
87. Baywatch
88. Snatched
89. Wilson
90. Queen of the Desert
91. The House
92. Sleepless
93. All Eyez on Me
94. The Book of Henry
95. The Space Between Us
2. Phantom Thread
3. The Shape of Water
4. Get Out
5. Good Time
6. Mudbound
7. Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
8. Logan
9. The Post
10. Wonder Woman
11. The Big Sick
12. Wind River
13. Thor: Ragnarok
14. Logan Lucky
15. The Beguiled
16. The Meyerowitz Stories (New and Selected)
17. Star Wars: The Last Jedi
18. John Wick: Chapter 2
19. The Lost City of Z
20. First They Killed My Father
21. Darkest Hour
22. A Ghost Story
23. Spider-Man: Homecoming
24. I Don't Feel at Home in This World Anymore
25. It
26. Battle of the Sexes
27. Brad's Status
28. Okja
29. Norman: The Moderate Rise and Tragic Fall of a New York Fixer
30. Kong: Skull Island
31. It Comes at Night
32. Crown Heights
33. Split
34. 1922
35. Personal Shopper
36. Landline
37. Beatriz at Dinner
38. Chuck
39. Atomic Blonde
40. Wheelman
41. The Lego Batman Movie
42. Megan Leavey
43. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
44. Marshall
45. Menashe
46. Walking Out
47. American Made
48. Beauty and the Beast
49. Imperial Dreams
50. Gifted
51. Murder on the Orient Express
52. The Zookeeper's Wife
53. Free Fire
54. Win It All
55. The Wall
56. Life
57. My Cousin Rachel
58. Breathe
59. The Man Who Invented Christmas
60. Maudie
61. Sleight
62. Alone in Berlin
63. A United Kingdom
64. Trespass Against Us
65. The Mountain Between Us
66. War Machine
67. Happy Death Day
68. Lowriders
69. Justice League
70. To the Bone
71. Ghost in the Shell
72. Wakefield
73. Bright
74. The Hitman's Bodyguard
75. XXX: Return of Xander Cage
76. The Mummy
77. The Greatest Showman
78. Rough Night
79. King Arthur: Legend of the Sword
80. Sand Castle
81. The Circle
82. CHiPs
83. Death Note
84. The Belko Experiment
85. The Great Wall
86. Fist Fight
87. Baywatch
88. Snatched
89. Wilson
90. Queen of the Desert
91. The House
92. Sleepless
93. All Eyez on Me
94. The Book of Henry
95. The Space Between Us