Crazy Joe Declares War... and a Rat in the Midst?
Two bodies, a man and a woman, were discovered slumped over in the front seat of a parked Cadillac in a lot at La Guardia Airport in Queens, NY. Both had been shot in the head. Police later identified the bodies as that of Genovese Family capo Anthony "Little Augie Pisano" Carfano and a female companion, former Miss America contestant Jessica Drake. The killers were never found but police knew who was responsible. Even from an Atlanta prison, Vito Genovese still wielded considerable power. Carfano was the last of the Costello allies and by skipping the Apalachin Conference (where Genovese would formally declare his ascent to the top of the family), he had essentially signed his own death warrant.
Carfano and the hapless Jessica Drake
The top positions in the family now belonged exclusively to Genovese's most trusted allies. Jerry Catena and Mike Miranda were appointed underboss and consigliere respectively and both performed admirably in their roles while Genovese was away. Tommy Eboli and Philip "Benny Squint" Lombardo (so nicknamed because of his poor eyesight and huge eyeglass lenses) were promoted to the rank of capo to lead two of the twenty-odd crews making up the Genovese family at that time. Numbering an estimated 300-400 soldiers, the Genoveses were still a force to contend with in the underworld but most of their big names had either died or left the game and the new players had yet to appear on the law enforcement radar. With no "number one" to set their sights on, the Genovese Family slowly drifted into the shadows and out of the limelight - but losing none of their power of influence in the process.
Catena and rare surveillance photo of Genovese chatting with Miranda
Meanwhile, Carlo Gambino had become recognized by law enforcement and the news media as the capo di tutti capi, or boss of all bosses, despite the fact that that title had been abolished almost thirty years before. Gambino was cunning and shrewd, playing his enemies (and sometimes allies) against each other and reaping the benefits of any resultant fall out. This had carried him all the way to the top of his own family. Well-liked and revered by his underlings, Gambino would henceforward be known as "Don" Carlo, a sign of respect and admiration. His ally, Tommy Lucchese, shared much of the same qualities which allowed him to stay on top of his own family throughout the turbulent decade of the fifties as well as mutually benefit with his ally from the removal of men like Genovese.
At the same time, the Bonannos and the Profacis were starting to drift away from the other families in the Commission. Always seen as more conservative and "old school", these two families were smaller in size and contained much less influence and connections than the other three families. In addition, internal strife would rip these two families apart in the sixties and lead to consequences which would be still be felt decades later.
The Profacis were the first family to implode. Frank "Frankie Shots" Abbatemarco was a high earning Profaci family capo, making about 2.5 million dollars annually through bookmaking and numbers. Profaci was pleased and enjoyed the mounds of cash being handed over monthly by Frankie Shots as his share of the take as boss. But the soldiers of the Profaci family were beginning to tire from paying what they considered unfair shares of their profits - bosses always took a disproportionate share of a family's earnings but Profaci, an infinitely wealthy man, was always wanting more. Eventually, Abbatemarco started holding back on his payments to Joe. Joe confronted Abbatemarco and demanded $50,000 that he claimed Abbatemarco owed him. Frankie Shots refused to pay and raised the ire of Profaci who began to plot his elimination. Approaching Joe Gallo (one of three brothers who were members of Abbatemarco's crew), Profaci offered a deal - eliminate Frankie Shots and his crew and lucrative rackets would be his. Although the Gallos also resented Profaci's methods, Joe, never one to turn an opportunity for advancing his status down, agreed to whack Frankie Shots.
Montage of (clockwise, from left) "Frankie Shots" Abbatemarco, Joe Profaci, and "Crazy" Joe Gallo
Outside of a Brooklyn bar in November, 1959, Frankie Shots was ambushed by Joseph Gioelli and another man, possibly one of the Gallos. Before he could react, Abbatemarco was hit and stumbled back into the bar where the hitmen followed him, pumping several more shots into him before fleeing the scene. Joey Gallo was now in high spirits. After the hit, he contacted Profaci to formally assume control over Frankie Shots's rackets but was astounded to learn that Profaci now demanded another hit before leasing control of the crew to Joey: Frankie's son, Tony Abbatemarco. Not wanting to become a pawn in Profaci's game, Joey took a drastic step and declared war on the leadership of the Profaci family.
Joey Gallo relished being a gangster - he looked, talked, and acted the part to a tee. His crew included his two brothers, Larry and Albert ("Kid Blast"), Joe Gioelli, and an up and coming mobster by the name of Carmine Persico. All were killers (the Gallos and Persico were pegged by some as having whacked Albert Anastasia) and all were reckless - almost to a fault no thanks to their leader, who would soon earn his nickname, "Crazy Joe".
Joe (left) and Larry (right)
Gallo was the first to move. In January, 1961, he kidnapped underboss Joe Magliocco and three other high ranking Profaci family members, demanding a $100,000 ransom for their safe return. Profaci, who had escaped Joe's net and hurriedly rushed off to his Florida home, agreed to sit down with Gallo and put an end to the hostilities. The terms of the deal are not known in detail but evidently they were enough to please Gallo, who released his captives and settled back into normalcy. With his guard now down, Profaci planned his revenge by first luring Carmine Persico over to his side (using the same bait as he had used with Gallo - control of Carmine's own crew). Later that year, Joe Gioelli disappeared and a package appeared on the front steps of a Gallo hangout - Gioelli's clothes stuffed with dead fish, alluding that Gioelli was now "sleeping with the fishes." (Reenacted in
The Godfather, as if you needed to reminded). Larry Gallo was next on Profaci's hit list. He was lured into a bar by some of Profaci's men and upon sitting down for a drink was ambushed from behind by Persico (who had earned the nickname "The Snake" for his duplicity) with a garotte. With his life quickly slipping away, Larry was saved by the chance entry of an on-duty police officer. Surprising the would-be killers, the attempt on Larry Gallo's life was broken up as Persico and the others made a hasty exit. (This also inspired a scene in
The Godfather: Part II.)
Carmine "The Snake" Persico
Meanwhile, Joe Gallo was having a hard time earning with the warfare between the two factions. He began shaking down businesses for cash until one owner reported him to the police. Gallo was charged and convicted in December of '61, earning a 7 to 14 year sentence for extortion. Losing their leader, the Gallos still tried to carry on the struggle against the rest of the family. Outmanned and outgunned, they were at a distinct disadvantage but were dealt a favorable hand in June of 1962: old Joe Profaci had died of cancer. Leadership now passed to his brother-in-law, Joe Magliocco, who continued to battle the Gallos throughout the year.
Magliocco (left) and Profaci (right)
While the Profaci war was raging, Gambino and Lucchese were chagrined at all the negative attention the war was bringing. By secretly backing the Gallos and evening the playing field, the two mob kingpins were hopeful that Profaci's family would weaken so that they could take over some of its rackets. The timely death of Profaci certainly didn't hurt their chances.
Profaci's death wasn't the only prominent one in 1962. Lucky Luciano, the exiled founder of the Commission and mastermind of the mob, died of a massive heart attack in a Naples airport diner. His old buddy Joe Adonis, himself deported, brought a wreath to Lucky's funeral which read "So long, pal." The old guard was slowly fading away. Prior to the start of the Profaci-Gallo war, the regime of Fulgencio Batista was overthrown on New Year's Eve, 1958, down in Cuba, and Fidel Castro took power - outlawing gambling and shutting down the island's casinos and gambling dens. Lansky was celebrating the New Year in Cuba at the time and beat a hasty retreat out of the country. With his main money-making source gone and most of his allies dead or removed from power, Lansky decided to settle down with his millions and live a quiet life in Miami, Florida.
Lucky Luciano: 1897-1962
Back in New York, things weren't so quiet - internecine warfare within the Profaci family notwithstanding. Vito Genovese had grown distrustful of Anthony Strollo's leadership of the family in his absence. Genovese had begun to suspect that Strollo had cooperated with Gambino and Lucchese in setting up his arrest in order to take over the family. Additionally, Genovese learned that Strollo was still brazenly selling large amounts of narcotics - something which Genovese believed would hurt his chances for parole. In April of 1962, Strollo went missing. Presumed dead, his body was never recovered. In his place, Genovese appointed Tommy Eboli, "Chin" Gigante's old boxing manager, as acting boss. The sixties had started out turbulently for the mob, with warfare and upheaval threatening to break the Commission apart, but things were about to get worse. In 1963, Joe Valachi took the stand and broke the mafia's long-standing code of silence.