A recent Corny clip mentioned that Jim Herd wanted the Starrcade 89 Tournament style event to happen each year. So let's pretend Herd stays in power and the event proves successful and see what would have been booked each year.
Right off the bat I'm changing the "rules" to Survivor Series 91 booking where the World title match is booked outside of the gimmick.
Starrcade 90:
World Champ Sting vs The Black Scorpion
No 1 Con Tourney: Luger, Stan Hansen, Flair, Pillman (I could have put in El Gigante but HELL NO)
World tag title: Doom vs Windham and Arn
Tourney: Steiners, Hayes and Garvin, Steve Armstrong and Tracy Smothers, Saito and Muta (I could have done Youngbloods, Morton and Rich, One night only Skyscrapers, Master Blasters, Hughes/Madman or Zenk/Pillman if we move Pillman out of the singles scene.)
----
91:
World champ Lex Luger vs Ron Simmons
Tourney: Sting, Rick Rude, Cactus Jack, El Gigante (Dear Lord!)
World tag title: Steamboat/Dustin Rhodes vs Arn and Eaton
Tourney: Vader/Hughes, Steiner Bros, US Patriots, Hayes and Garvin
--
92
World champ Ron Simmons vs Vader
Tourney: Sting, Muta, Dr Death, Steve Austin
World Tag title: Douglas/Steamboat vs Windham/Pillman
Tourney: Johnny Gunn and Tom Zenk, Tex and Pierce, Cactus and Barbarian, Sasaki and Liger (Where have all the team's gone....gone to graveyards one by one....) Uhhhh... DDP and Vinne Vegas are left in the cold. Can we find Eaton a partner? Mr. Wonderful? 2 Cold?
--
93
World Champ Vader vs Flair
Tourney: Steamboat, Rhodes, Rude, Austin
World tag: Nasty Boyz vs Hawk and Sting
Tourney: Cactus and Maxx, Roma/Orndorff, Harlem Heat, 2 Cold and Bagwell (Left out are The Kongs, Tex and Pierce, Thunder and Lightning, The Cole Twins)
----
94:
World Champ Hogan vs Butcher
Tourney: Vader, Sting, Avalanche, Rhodes (Sorry Duggan! So close Arn! It was tempting Bossman!!)
World tag Patriot/Bagwell vs Pretty Wonderful
Tourney: Nasty Boys, Harlem Heat, Buck and Slater, Regal and Jean Paul Levesque (Sorry Armstrong Bros!)
--
95
World champ Savage vs Flair
Tourney: Sting, Luger, Sasaki, Arn Anderson (Hogan's gone. The Giant will be written out somehow to preserve all the fresh main event matches with him- he was on "probation" storyline wise)
World Tag Harlem Heat vs Chono and Tenzan (Let's give it the international flavor instead of a stale match)
Tourney: Eaton and Regal, American Males, Meng and Kurasawa, Pillman and Beniot (No dice Men at Work, Tempted to put DDP/Max Muscle in for ATM Eric, Buck and Slater lose out to Parker's other men, Barrio Bros (LOL), Armstrong Family, Super Assassins, sorry Nasties!)
---
96
World champ Hogan vs Roddy Piper
Tourney: Luger, the Giant (NWO), DDP, Eddy (Eddy was being elevated ATM)
World tag Hall and Nash vs Faces of Fear
Tourney: Benoit and Arn, Amazing French Canadians, Public Enemy, Nasty Boys, (No go to High Voltage, Renegade/Joe Gomez, Enos and Buck, Armstrong Family, Scott Steiner was out injured. Regal is TV champ so the Bluebloods are off the hook.)
-------
97
World Hogan vs Sting
Tourney: DDP, Hennig (NWO), Bret Hart (Canada), Ric Flair (seems to have missed the PPV with a worked injury)
World tag Steiner Bros vs Buff and Norton
Tourney: Giant and Luger, Savage and Scott Hall (NWO) (Nash's "heart attack" incident), Harlem Heat (T is about to start his singles push), Wrath and Mortis (Maybe next year for Disorderly Conduct, Ernest Miller and Glacier, Faces of Fear, The Flock, Regal and Taylor, Public Enemy, Villianos, etc)
--------
98
World champ Goldberg vs Nash
Tourney: DDP, Jericho (still chasing that elusive Goldberg match), Scott Steiner (nWo Black and White), Scott Hall (nWo Red and Black)
World tag champs: Vacant (Last held by Rick Steiner and Judy Bagwell) So the tourney will be for the new champs:
Benoit and Malenko (Horseman), Konnan and Luger (Red and Black nWo), Giant and Stevie Ray (nWo Black and white), Eddy and Juvi (LWO)
---
99
World champ Bret Hart vs Goldberg (oh no!)
Tourney: Sting, Beniot, Sid, THE CHOSEN ONE Jeff Jarrett (Leaving out Luger..excuse me THE TOTAL PACKAGE, Vampiro, Nash, DDP, Flair, Dustin Rhodes, etc)
World tag titles...wait for it.... Vacant!
Tourney: Harris Boys, Mamalukes, Saturn and Malenko (Revolution), Harlem Heat (PG 13, Rotundo and Dr Death, Lash and Disco, Berlyn and the Wall, Villanos, Disorderly Conduct, Fit Finlay and Knobbs,
--
2000 (Kill me)
World Scott Steiner vs Sid
Goldberg, Terry Funk (Fuck it we'll book it as a Legends last stand), Shane Douglas, Jeff Jarrett
World tag: Chuck Palumbo and Sean Stasiak vs DDP and Nash
Tourney: Kronik, Lance Storm and Elix Skipper , Sean O Haire and Jindrak, Kidman and Rey (Sympathies to 3 Count, Jung Dragons, Vito and Reno, Buff and Lex, Gen Rection's crew etc