Do a tag title rematch of MJF/Cole vs FTR with the stip that if MJF and Cole lose they can never team again. Obviously under normal circumstances it would be too soon for that stipulation but since they’ve treated this whole storyline like a joke it could work because if they lost everyone would know that the break up angle was coming. But they should win the titles and keep spinning the wheels for a while.
OK this obviously isn't happening at All Out but I still think it's the direction they should go with. I would drag out the MJF/Cole stuff as long as possible - maybe into the new year before the turn. During the Steamboat-Starks match at the PPV, Taven and Bennett run in and try to help Ricky but MJF and Cole, having already defended their ROH belts earlier in the night, run out to even the odds and help Steamboat win. Then on Dynamite, Roddy goes to Matt and Mike and he's like "wtf since when are you guys friends with Ricky Starks." And they're like "hey we can be friends with whoever we want." Then MJF and Cole recruit Roddy to their side with the power of friendship and they win the trios belts, which they then defend vs Starks/Taven/Bennett. The three of them can go on a quest to win every men's belt in the company, leading to fun matches with Joe, Claudio, Hook, and Moxley (who I assume will beat OC on Sunday.) Maybe through Starks you can find a way to work Punk and his "real" world title somewhere in there if and when he comes back. You should be able to get a few months out of that.
I don't know if any of these ideas are good but the point is that when you have something that's over and draws ratings, you have to milk it until everyone is tired of it. That's the story of current WWE and really any successful promotion prior to the Attitude Era. I hope Tony has the patience and restraint to see it through.
FAKE EDIT: Oh and I forgot to the winner of Darby vs Luchasaurus in the title thing. They have too many belts.