Waters has spent so much of his life as a twat that I can't go against Gilmour ever. I'd argue, though, that in terms of longevity vs quality, Pink Floyd is the most consistent band of all time. The Final Cut is still trash.
Friend and I got into a Gary Numan discussion as I guess he has a new album. Came down to an argument over whether "Cars" is annoying or not. I've never liked it much. Repetitive as fuck, influence aside. Doesn't "fucking suck" but I just came to the realization I didn't like it very much and it gets played frequently. His new stuff is quality, though.