Re: Conan Blows
I agree that they didn't give Conan a chance, but they were put in a tough spot where they had to choose one or the other. And in the choice between someone with a proven track record of success or someone who was losing to Letterman in every category, what do you do? I don't see that the public would eventually embrace Conan after a couple of years in the spot. Conan isn't, and wasn't, some unknown quantity. He got huge ratings that first week he hosted Tonight and then the public tuned out. They gave him a chance and didn't like what they saw. Of course The Jay Leno Show was a horrible idea, but the 10PM shows they have now really aren't doing much better. Now if NBC had a big roster of hit shows to help provide a strong lead-in for the local news, and thus to Conan's Tonight Show, OR if they were planning to remake the entire schedule and focus on attracting young male viewers, he might have been worth taking a chance on but when you have so much that isn't working, I can't blame them for sticking with something that does, that being Leno at 11:30. The network was caught in a situation where they had to look at their options and determine if they were willing to let Jay Leno go and compete against them. They would have seen that as the necessary decision if they believed that Conan's Tonight Show had the potential to become a major hit with the 18-49 demographic, but they apparently didn't think there was a chance of that happening. I can't say for sure that they were right but Conan's TBS ratings haven't done anything to convince me otherwise. You can say nobody would have done well in that spot but track record has to count for something, doesn't it? And as much money as they had to eat on Conan's contract, they would have had to eat a lot more on Leno's pay-and-play deal.
To be honest, I don't think Jeff Zucker ever really wanted Conan to host the Tonight Show. That deal he made in 2004 was mainly made with the intention of ensuring five more years of the successful Leno/Conan lineup. Conan getting the Tonight Show was the deal he had to make in order to protect his late-night schedule but I don't believe he was fully committed to the idea.