I've got one guy I just can't seem to do anything with. He's a hoss, basically. A* Power and Menace, A Looks and Star Quality, lots of Fs and lots of C-'s. Apparantly, he's "awful" in the ring and should be kept away from a live microphone "at all costs". Which is kinda bad. I tried debuting him with some squashes and got C-'s and Ds aplenty. I put a decent manager with him and still only got C ratings for interviews. Video packages, C ratings. Yet for some reason, his popularity jumped quickly up and before I knew it I was being told to stick him as an Upper Midcarder.
The kicker is, I've started putting him against better opponents to cover the fact that he sucks. The match ratings are going up, but his popularity has regressed back to where it was to start. He was more popular having D grade matches than B grade.