Rico wasn't good. His OVW stuff is fun but nothing super special, and I think he was great managing Billy and Chuck with the stylist gimmick. It seemed like when the Street knockoff gimmick started up, he aged significantly (I know he was already older) and looked in rough shape, and he and Jackie Gayda did not click whatsoever. More than anything it was WWE seeing the gimmick as more just a gay gimmick than as a flamboyant badass like Street was. Needed to be Hugh Jackman in The Greatest Showman on the outside with Wolverine on the inside, man.